Sunday, 8 April 2007

2006-07 Off-Season UFA's (Goalie Update)


The cream of the crop has been winnowed to:

Giguere

Backstrom

Garon

Smith

From my last post (here) the changes are (in no particular order):

1. Backstrom finishing 23-8-6 with a .929 sv%
-- Those are 'wow' kind of numbers. With any brains at all his agent is telling him to go Unrestricted. With Kolzig's best years coming to an end Washington would be stupid not to pursue this guy.

2. Biron signs with Philly.
-- Signed a two-year deal with an average Cap hit of $ 3.5 m/yr. Good deal for both sides.

3. Garon finishes with 32 gp / 13-10-6 with a .907 sv%.
-- The key is the decent sv% on a bad team. With Cap and Salary inflation considered Garon represents a GREAT signing if he can be picked up for less than $ 2.0 m/yr. On a multi-year deal it would be a stellar signing imo.

4. Dunham is just plain awful
-- He had a chance to garner attention and totally blew it.

5. Smith finishes okay.
-- Not enough games to decide much and his team (Dallas) was pretty good overall but a .912 sv% over 23 games should garner attention. It won't but it should.

6. Giguere and Bryzgalov finish well.
-- Giguere is one good play-off run away from $ 6.0+ m/yr - if Burke lets him go I surmise that Anaheim's NEXT season will not be as good as this last one simply because Bryz. isn't as good as Giguere.

I have to think that Giguere and Backstrom are the class of this UFA goalie crop.

I still expect Burke to sign Giguere but who knows with Burke. I have a lot of respect for him as a GM however and it wouldn't surprise me if he let Giguere go and signed Backstrom.

Backstrom, as noted, should be a hot commodity but one never knows with player preferences, he may re-up with Minny even though the smart money says to test free agency - there are a lot of teams out there with poor (Tampa), mediocre (Columbus), aging (Detroit, Florida, Edmonton and Washington) or combo of the same (Phoenix) goaltenders out there and there is only one young goalie with exceptional numbers available.
------
Have a great evening everyone.

Friday, 6 April 2007

Inflation Calculator for the NHL


The following is an inflation charting series for the NHL. A visual calculator of sorts.

According to the CBA the players are guaranteed a % of leaguewide Hockey Related Revenues (HRR). That % changes as HRR shrinks or grows but can never fall below 54% (at $ 2.2 billion in HRR) and never go above 57% (at $ 2.7 billion in HRR).

Chart One

The first chart gives the Salary Cap # per team based on the estimated leaguewide HRR.

$b ........ Player % / $m ..... Cap $m

2.200 ..... 54.0 / 1.188 ..... 39.60
2.300 ..... 55.5 / 1.277 ..... 42.55
2.400 ..... 56.0 / 1.344 ..... 44.80
2.500 ..... 56.3 / 1.408 ..... 46.92
2.550 ..... 56.5 / 1.441 ..... 48.03
2.600 ..... 56.7 / 1.474 ..... 49.14
2.700 ..... 57.0 / 1.539 ..... 51.30
2.800 ..... 57.0 / 1.596 ..... 53.20
2.900 ..... 57.0 / 1.653 ..... 55.10
3.000 ..... 57.0 / 1.710 ..... 57.00

Chart Two

The next chart shows the effect of actual, and projected, inflation during the course of the CBA.

Given the factual inflation numbers generated 2005-06 and 2006-07, the remaining estimates of 2% a year are conservative in nature. Max Salary, the 2nd last column, represents the most any one player can be paid by any one team in each respective team. Bonus points (not worth anything) to anyone who figures out what the last column represents.

Year ..... Inflatn ... $b ... Player % / $m ..... Max Sal ... ??

2005-06 .. _._% .. 2.20 .. 54.0_% .. 39.600 .. _7.92 .. 13.9%
2006-07 .. 9.1% .. 2.40 .. 56.0_% .. 44.800 .. _8.96 .. 12.3%
2007-08 .. 6.3% .. 2.55 .. 56.5_% .. 48.025 .. _9.60 .. 11.5%
2008-09 .. 2.0% .. 2.60 .. 56.7_% .. 49.159 .. _9.83 .. 11.2%
2009-10 .. 2.0% .. 2.65 .. 56.85% .. 50.275 .. 10.05 .. 10.9%
2010-11 .. 2.0% .. 2.71 .. 57.0_% .. 51.416 .. 10.28 .. 10.7%
2011-12 .. 2.0% .. 2.76 .. 57.0_% .. 52.444 .. 10.49 .. 10.5%

Interesting to note that the Cap number will be near, or exceed, the $ 52 mill/yr mark by the end of the deal. At that point in time I would have to figure that we are right back to where we started before the lock-out - low revenue teams simply won't be able to compete with their larger budget brethren.

It will be very interesting to see what happen with actual salary inflation in the future. For a player to break the $ 7 mill/yr mark it may be a major accomplishment.

BTW: I tried to do the Cap floor calculations given in the CBA copy I printed out - the results didn't quite match up to what made sense to me so if anyone wants to comment on that feel free. i.e. the CBA language indicates that the 2005-06 number should be ~ $ 23.6 million but the math they gave returns a number of $ 31.6 million. The 23.6 is closer to 'right' but I didn't want to muddy the chart with numbers that could easily be wrong.

------

Have a great evening everyone.

Tuesday, 27 March 2007

Hockey - Rule Changes - YKOil Edition

Going to be on the road for work reasons for a week so I figured I would write up a quick post on some miscellaneous items:

A) don't miss this post by Vic over at IOF - absolute gold
B) great 'history was, history is' post over at Lowetide's
C) CIO discusses various rule changes he would like to see and in that spirit I include a few comments of mine own (below).


Immediate Rule Changes in the world of YKOil:

1) Player helmets have to be properly strapped on. Failure to do so is an automatic 2 minute penalty.

--- I have heard that the proper distance between the strap and the bottom of the chin is approximately a fingerwidth. If so, then that is what it should be.

Safety first. This is a no-brainer. Pun intended.

2) No touch icing at the plane of the goal line.

--- if the puck passes the plane of the goal line and there is no apparent pursuit of the puck** it is whistled down as automatic icing

--- if pursuit of the puck is apparent and the defenseman reaches the plane of the goal line first the whistle blows and it is automatic icing.

--- if pursuit of the puck is apparent and the forward reaches the plane of the goal line first then playcontinues on

Pursuit of the puck is a rule of thumb term best given in the form of two rhetorical questions:

a) Is there a player(s) chasing the puck?
b) Is the players(s) in question able to overtake the puck before it hits the boards?

If the answer to either question results in a 'no' response then there is no apparent pursuit of the puck. Should speed up the game and result in markedly fewer injuries while sltill allowing the odd foot-chase to occur.

3) Change the goal posts. Not the shape or size of the net - just the goal posts.

--- I have attached a crude drawing (above) to this post that shows what I am aiming at. Admittedly I am not the greatest student of physics and geometry but even I know that the half-post concept would result in fewer pucks deflecting away from the goal line.

--- in this age of high-tech metal composites I do not believe that shrinking the post would result in dramatically weaker net frames.

--- an important side benefit is that a 1 inch shave would result in an extra 168 inches of open net (just over 1 square foot)

More net to shoot at, more shots counting for goals and a committment to the traditional dimensions of the frame... what's not to love?

So there you have it - were I commish for a day those would be my changes.

------

Have a great evening everyone. See you in a week.

Monday, 26 March 2007

Risk Management & Hockey


Risk management is an old concept in management circles that has, as concepts in management circles are wont to do, come around again (last 5 years or so).

The basics are very simple:

Step 1: identify all risks to the company

Step 2: categorize them according to ability to control them

Step 3: ascertain liklihood of risk (LOW, MEDIUM, HIGH)

Step 4: ascertain impact of risk if it does occur (L, M, H)

Step 5: determine controls that can eliminate or manage risk

Step 6: institute those controls that are cost effective at eliminating or managing risk

Step 7: audit said controls AND solutions for economy, efficiency and effectiveness

Step 8: periodically examine, fresh, Steps 1 though 7 and note that this is an ongoing cycle

Done. Some common examples of the Steps in question are these:

Step 3: odds of a chocolate bar being stolen from a convenience store candy rack - HIGH
Step 4: impact of that loss - individually - LOW - collectively - HIGH
Step 5: putting security mirrors in place, and training staff to be alert to and discourage theft are more cost effective than, say, training a tiger to guard the chocolate bars
Step 6: install mirrors and train staff

and

Step 3: odds of Hoover Dam failing - LOW
Step 4: impact if fails - REALLY REALLY REALLY REALLY HIGH

etc.

That is it kids. You just received thousands of dollars in management training. Wheeee.

Some other examples are these:

Step 1: poor goaltending is a risk to having a winning season and making the play-offs
Step 2: team management can control the risk by contracting or trading for a good goalie
Step 3: odds that current goaltending will fail - MEDIUM
Step 4: impact if fail - HIGH (no play-off revenues, etc.)
Step 5: control: monitor performance of goaltending vs. team: if team performs well and goaltending is the problem then trade for goalie
Step 6: monitor performance of team vs. goaltending
Step 7: control is good but original solution, while economic, is not efficient or effective - replace goaltender
Step 8: monitor anew


AND

Step 1: poor depth AND experience level on defense is a risk to having a winning season and making the play-offs
Step 2: team management can control the risk by contracting or trading for defensemen
Step 3: odds that current defense will fail due to injury and/or capability deficiencies or both - HIGH
Step 4: impact if fail - HIGH (no play-off revenues, etc.)
Step 5: control: monitor performance of defense vs. team: if team performs well and defense is the problem then trade for better/more defensemen
Step 6: monitor performance of team vs. defense
Step 7: control is good but original solution, while economic, is not efficient or effective - goaltending is good but team offense is bad - replacement of enough defense to compensate is probably too expensive; do nothing in regards to defense
Step 8: wait for next season

Interesting eh? Oiler team management might just be using risk management analysis. Good on 'em.

Except.

Well.

Except for the fact that proper risk analysis in the second scenario would actually, probably, look like so:

Step 1: poor depth AND experience level on defense is a risk to having a winning season and making the play-offs
Step 2: team management can control the risk given budget and cap space
Step 3: odds that current defense will fail due to injury and/or capability deficiencies or both - HIGH in both cases indicates VERY HIGH
Step 4: impact if fail - HIGH (no play-off revenues, etc.)
Step 5: control: examine UFA market for a defenseman who can improve depth and/or experience level OR both of the defense / also examine teams for defensemen for trade
Step 6: monitor cost of adding said defenseman against cap and budget space
Step 7: control is good and given presence of UFA's that fit the parameter (Markov, Eaton, etc) and possible trade opportunities (Vishnevski, Matvichuk, etc) solution is economic, efficient and effective
Step 8: implement solution and begin cycle anew

Hrmmmm... different... I submit to you that the Oiler's management is either poor at risk management analysis or knew the risk going into the season and didn't really care.

i.e. they accepted the MUCH higher than average risk that the team wouldn't make the play-offs

Make your own conclusions accordingly. Mine is quite simple: they knew this season was apt to happen and were quite okay with it, which means that it isn't that they planned to have it - it is that they didn't plan to avoid it and by doing so committed that which is not easily forgivable of a professional sports team - they planned to fail.

------

Have a great evening everyone.

Thursday, 22 March 2007

Competitive Budgets - A Rough Guide

Figured I would actually chart out all of the budget stuff I did previously.

As before, 'best%' is roughly that which a competitive team (being a team that expects to make the post-season) should hold back in their budget to allow for injuries and deadline trades. At the bottom of the chart is the target Cap for said teams.

'Max' is maximum salary one player can make. '35%' and '50%' are percentages of that and the numbers below those are given a rounding-off effect (no one talks about players signing for $2.73 million - it's always 2.75 or 3.00, etc).

Cap .... 39.00 .. 44.00 .. 48.00 .. 52.00 .. 56.00

10% ..... 3.90 ... 4.40 ... 4.80 ... 5.20 ... 5.60

best% .... 8% ..... 6% ..... 5% ..... 5% ..... 5%

Cap space available at Day
_01 ..... 3.12 ... 2.64 ... 2.40 ... 2.60 ... 2.80
_42 ..... 4.02 ... 3.40 ... 3.10 ... 3.35 ... 3.61
_94 ..... 6.27 ... 5.31 ... 4.83 ... 5.23 ... 5.63
146 .... 14.23 .. 12.04 .. 10.95 .. 11.86 .. 12.77

max ..... 7.80 ... 8.80 ... 9.60 .. 10.40 .. 11.20
35% ..... 2.73 ... 3.08 ... 3.36 ... 3.64 ... 3.92
= ~ ..... 2.75 ... 3.25 ... 3.50 ... 3.75 ... 4.00
50% ..... 3.90 ... 4.40 ... 4.80 ... 5.20 ... 5.60
= ~ ..... 4.00 ... 4.50 ... 5.00 ... 5.50 ... 6.00

Cap space available given 35% signing mid-season
_01 ..... 3.12 ... 2.64 ... 2.40 ... 2.60 ... 2.80
_42 ..... 4.02 ... 3.40 ... 3.10 ... 3.35 ... 3.61
_94 ..... 3.52 ... 2.06 ... 1.33 ... 1.48 ... 1.63
146 ..... 7.94 ... 4.61 ... 2.97 ... 3.28 ... 3.65


Cap target at best%
target = 35.88 .. 41.36 .. 45.60 .. 49.40 .. 53.20

Notes:

a) the 'best%' numbers leave more than enough Cap space in the bank; even with injury call-ups taken into effect (2% seems about right)

b) competitive teams may spend more or less than target but the reason for such should be readily apparent (veteran heavy roster if more or a 'Crosby' effect if less)

c) the 35% and 50% numbers represent decent salary approximations for competitive players at those Cap levels - note that inflation is built into this model

d) the 35% player signing depletes Cap reserve substantially but remember that we are NOT assuming any player salary is traded away in this model

Those are all my notes for now. I may add later. I hope this is a useful reference tool. Remember - if a team is NOT spending to target then they are, absent some damn good reason (i.e. Crosby) probably not competitive.

------

Have a great evening everyone.

Sunday, 18 March 2007

Are They Really THAT Stupid? (with better math!)

Being stupid, or mistaken, or even mistakenly stupid every now and then is perfectly fine. I, myself, am perfectly good at such things. Being permanently stupid however, especially when one should not be, is something I cannot abide very well at all.

Hence my thanks to kinger. He pointed out a flaw in my last post that, this being a blog, I can now correct.

When calculating the linear nature of the value of cap space as the year progresses I had, mistakenly, used 'games played' as my factor of measurement. The true factor however is 'days in the season'. In the NHL all things salary consider only the regular season so, stealing again from kinger, the number of days is 187.

The cap is, of course, $44 million. The proposed savings rates are 10% and then 5% respectively.

Where before I had this chart:

Game .. 10% ............... Game .. 5%

01 = _4.4 million .......... 01 = 2.2 million
20 = _5.8 million .......... 20 = 2.9 million
41 = _8.8 million .......... 41 = 4.4 million
60 = 16.4 million .......... 60 = 8.2 million

I now have this chart:

Days .. 10% ................ Days .. 5%

_01 = _4.4 million .......... _01 = _2.2 million

_47 = _5.9 million .......... _47 = _2.9 million
_94 = _8.8 million .......... _94 = _4.4 million
146 = 20.0 million .......... 146 = 10.0 million


Now. Bonus time. Simple budget exercise. Let's use the prudent 10%.

Our one assumption is this - we will assume that the team using prudent budgeting starts the season with a more than realistic chance they should make the play-offs. Not a borderline team and not an elite team but a team that should finish comfortably in the top-6 in their conference.

This is important because from this all logic flows. Think about it:

-- A team that isn't ready to compete should be (I won't go into the math - just trust me I am right on this):

---- saving far more than the 5% and
---- front-loading their important contracts and
---- spending dollars on mercenary UFA's they will trade later

-- A team that is elite is usually at or near the cap regardless because they have to spend all they can to compete for the Cup.

-- A team that is touch and go to make the play-offs has to decide if they will act like a team that isn't ready or a team that will make every effort to make the play-offs, thus spending to the cap.

-- Given that a team that is touch and go has no room for prudence it is only the teams in between those scenario's that have the ability to practice the arcane art of deliberately saving 10%.

Basic, simple logic. One who does not follow it is mistaken in their approach. One who does not follow it more than once approaches stupidity.

Our NEW chart follows this paragraph. Our intrepid, yet prudent manager, notices that 50% of the way through the season his team is not performing up to snuff. His team is now a touch-n-go team and that is simply not good enough. He makes a trade for a $3.5 million d-man. He could even be named Zhitnik for example (not a perfect example but it is pretty good and it does serve the point).

Days .. 10%

_01 = _4.4 million .......... _01 = _4.4 million
_47 = _5.9 million .......... _47 = _5.9 million
_94 = _8.8 million .......... _94 = _5.3 million (8.8 - 3.5 = 5.3)
146 = 20.0 million .......... 146 = 12.1 million

So. Still $12.1 million in cap space to spend at the deadline. How about 5%?

Days .. 5%

_01 = _2.2 million .......... _01 = _2.2 million
_47 = _2.9 million .......... _47 = _2.9 million
_94 = _4.4 million .......... _94 = _0.9 million (4.4 - 3.5 = 0.9)
146 = 10.0 million .......... 146 = _2.0 million


Interesting isn't it? 5% is quite serviceable all said and done. Not great because the manager would have to dump salary at the deadline to get a higher salaried player BUT it is still serviceable.

The perfect number is (for a cap of $44 million), believe it or not, ~ 6%.

Days .. 6%

_01 = _2.64 million .......... _01 = 2.64 million
_47 = _3.53 million .......... _47 = 3.53 million
_94 = _5.31 million .......... _94 = 1.81 million
146 = 12.04 million .......... 146 = 4.06 million

10% remains... stupid. 6% is more than enough to add significant salary and provide for injury replacements from the minors. With the cap going up to $48 million or so next year the 6% figure is probably still worthwhile.

Important to note - even for a team that figures it is a lock for the play-offs - the cap/payroll $ should have been no less than $41.36 million (using the 6% strategy).

------

Have a great evening everyone.

Thursday, 15 March 2007

Are They Really THAT Stupid?

Recent commentary from Laforge casts aspersions on Smyth's character. mc79hockey covers it well. I cannot honestly say at what time the Edmonton hockey media gave away their integrity to the EIG but it is getting to be impossible to refute.

The hard part for me is that I used to really liked Matheson. Grew up with the guy.

HOF my ass.

Anyways. What REALLY caught my eye was the little gem regarding the teams salary budget salary - namely holding back 10% DELIBERATELY so as to spend it later if they felt they were close and needed to bring in some big salaries in order to make a real run at the Cup.

Seems prudent. Using the $44 million cap for 2006/07 the number is $4.4 million. Cool.

Thinking about it a little, and knowing that:

- the value of cap space rises in a linear fashion just as
- the cost of assuming a salary falls in a linear fashion

I figure the amount of salary that $4.4 million can buy at differing points in the season is:

Game

01 = 4.4 million
20 = 5.8 million
41 = 8.8 million
60 = 16.4 million
80 = 180.4 million

hrmmmm.

Oh.

I see the problem.

THEY NEED TO BUY SOME F&*%#NG CALCULATORS!

Un-freakin-believable that Laforge can spew a line like that and it is accepted at face value. Heck - he'll probably get credit for thinking 'smart'.

For a team that CAN spend to the salary cap, per the following chart, saving any more than 5% is just an exercise in saving money.

Game

01 = 2.2 million
20 = 2.9 million
41 = 4.4 million
60 = 8.2 million


Being able to add $8.2 million of salary cap space is lots - even if there is no salary headed the other way. Being able to add $18.4 million is more than HALF of the level of the cap floor - a team that needs to add that kind of salary was never competitive to begin with.

Which brings us right to our Oilers.

The team had, even with prudence in mind, enough cash to bring in a guy like Markov or Eaton as an UFA or even make a trade for a guy like Matvichuk or Lukowich. For the team not to do so, knowing how weak they were on defense, is indefensible.

------

Have a great evening everyone.